Updated November 2026 · 41 verified insurance agencies · CAN-SPAM-aware

Insurance Agencies in Fayetteville, North Carolina — 41 verified insurance agencies, 11 with email

A clean, deduplicated database of every operational insurance agency across Fayetteville and surrounding North Carolina, sourced from public listings and enriched with business email addresses, SMTP-checked before delivery. 4 corporate emails (info@, contact@, hello@) plus 7 webmail. Instant CSV download.

Total Insurance Agencies
41
Across Fayetteville
With Email
11
27% of listings · 36% corporate domain
Avg Rating
4.52/5
3,491 total reviews
Top Rated
29
Rated 4.5 or higher

The Fayetteville, North Carolina insurance agencies list has 41 businesses, 11 of them with a business email. Each record has the business name, phone, address, website and Google rating. One-time $9 USD — download Excel and CSV right after checkout, no subscription.

/ 01 — Sample previewSee what's in the file

Five rows from the full 41-row dataset, sorted by rating & review count. The full file has one row per business with 16 columns: business name, email, email type (business or personal), phone, street address (with postal code), city, state/province, country, Google rating, review count, website, email quality, audit date, and any other emails and phones we found for the business with where we found them. The CSV adds email_2, email_3… where a business has more than one address. Service-area businesses (mobile mechanics, handymen, cleaners) deliberately don’t list an address on Google, so that column is blank for about 2% of rows.

insurance-agencies-fayetteville-nc-usa.xlsx / .csv · 41 rows · 16 columnsPREVIEW
NameRatingReviewsEmail
RK Prater - State Farm Insurance Agent★ 5.0242—
Insurance Service Center-Agent Sarah Sanders★ 5.0177s***@iscfay.com
Ethan Gardner - State Farm Insurance Agent★ 5.0157—
Lukas Belletete★ 5.0139—
Austin Fitzpatrick - State Farm Insurance Agent★ 5.065—
+ 36 more rows in the full downloadExcel · CSV

/ 02 — Market insightFayetteville's insurance agencies market in numbers

“

Fayetteville holds one of the largest concentrations of insurance agencies in North Carolina at 41 active operations. The market is mature: 10% of operators have corporate domain emails (a strong signal of established branding) and the average business carries 85 reviews on Google. For B2B sellers, this means a market that responds to professional outreach at high-quality email addresses.

41
Active insurance agencies
10%
Corporate domain emails
85
Avg Google reviews

/ The dataFayetteville insurance agencies: ratings, email, hours and categories

Google ratings

All 41 insurance agencies in Fayetteville have a Google rating. Of those, 29 are rated 4.5 or higher, 7 between 4.0 and 4.4, 4 between 3.0 and 3.9 and 1 below 3.0. 12 have 100 or more Google reviews.

4.5 and higher29
71%
4.0 – 4.47
17%
3.0 – 3.94
10%
Below 3.01
2%
No rating yet0
0%

Email addresses

11 of the 41 have an email address we could verify. Of those, 4 are on the business's own domain and 7 on another domain, such as Gmail or Outlook. The other 30 have no verified email.

Own-domain email4
10%
Other email (Gmail, Outlook …)7
17%
No email30
73%

Opening hours

All 41 list their opening hours on Google. Of those, 4 are open on Saturday or Sunday and 1 on Sunday.

Hours listed41
100%
Open at the weekend4
10%
Open on Sunday1
2%
Open 24 hours0
0%

Google categories

Google files these 41 insurance agencies under 4 categories. The most common are Insurance agency (36), Auto insurance agency (2), Health insurance agency (2) and Insurance broker (1).

Insurance agency36
88%
Auto insurance agency2
5%
Health insurance agency2
5%
Insurance broker1
2%

ZIP codes

The 41 with a postal code sit in 8 ZIP codes. The busiest are 28304 (16), 28303 (6), 28305 (6), 28314 (6) and 28301 (4).

2830416
39%
283036
15%
283056
15%
283146
15%
283014
10%

Compared with North Carolina

71% of Fayetteville's insurance agencies are rated 4.5 or higher, against 60% of the 801 across North Carolina. 27% have an email address we could verify, against 39% across North Carolina. 10% open at the weekend, against 10% across North Carolina.

Rated 4.5+ — Fayetteville29
71%
Rated 4.5+ — North Carolina484
60%
With email — Fayetteville11
27%
With email — North Carolina314
39%

/ 03 — Built forWho buys this list

A

Agency management systems

Applied Epic, AMS360, EZLynx, HawkSoft, and rating-engine platforms selling to independent insurance agencies.

B

Carrier appointment programs

Wholesale brokers, MGA / MGU partners, surplus-lines carriers, and direct-appointment programs building agency networks.

C

Marketing & lead gen

EverQuote, NetQuote, insurance-specific SEO agencies, and review / referral platforms targeting independent agents.

/ 04 — QuestionsFrequently asked

What exactly is in the download?+

A row per business with name, phone, postal code, website URL, parent domain, Google rating, review count, the email address where one was found, and the street address where the business publishes one (service-area businesses don't list one on Google) — as CSV, XLSX and JSON. The five-row preview above is drawn live from the file you will receive.

Can I use this list for cold email outreach under CAN-SPAM?+

These are publicly-listed business contacts, not an opt-in email list. Buying this list is not a compliance guarantee and this is not legal advice — you are responsible for evaluating CAN-SPAM and any other applicable law for your own campaign, and should talk to a lawyer if you are unsure. Our Compliance & Responsible Use page sets out the specific rules.

Data sourcing, update frequency, bundle pricing & refunds →

/ 05 — Browse moreOther insurance agencies lists in United States

/ DirectoryBrowse Insurance Agencies in Fayetteville

Find a verified insurance agency near you. Get directions or visit their website directly — sorted by Google rating.

RK Prater - State Farm Insurance Agent

★ 5.0 · 242 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Insurance Service Center-Agent Sarah Sanders

★ 5.0 · 177 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Ethan Gardner - State Farm Insurance Agent

★ 5.0 · 157 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Lukas Belletete

★ 5.0 · 139 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Austin Fitzpatrick - State Farm Insurance Agent

★ 5.0 · 65 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Bruce Jackson Agency: Allstate Insurance

★ 5.0 · 46 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Independent Insurance Group DBA: Triangle Risk Advisors, Inc

★ 5.0 · 10 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Sean Mayer, Bankers Life Agent and Bankers Life Securities Financial Representative

★ 5.0 · 5 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Bankers Life

★ 5.0 · 2 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Tisdale Karen

★ 5.0 · 2 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Globe Life Liberty National Division: The Phelps Agencies

★ 5.0 · 2 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Beyond Blue Neighborhood Center Fayetteville

★ 5.0 · 1 review
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Dan Heiman Insurance Agency, Inc

★ 4.9 · 399 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Hayes McDowell - State Farm Insurance Agent

★ 4.9 · 391 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Hurley Insurance Group

★ 4.9 · 184 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Thomas Owen - State Farm Insurance Agent

★ 4.9 · 162 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Ai insurance

★ 4.9 · 140 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Insurance of the Carolinas

★ 4.9 · 116 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Warren Insurance Group - A Highstreet Partner

★ 4.9 · 61 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

The Barge Group

★ 4.8 · 320 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Statewide Insurance

★ 4.8 · 71 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Ann McLeod - State Farm Insurance Agent

★ 4.8 · 58 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Rodney Sherrill - State Farm Insurance Agent

★ 4.7 · 197 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Tim McAuley - State Farm Insurance Agent

★ 4.7 · 87 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Insurance Service Center

★ 4.7 · 18 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Olde Fayetteville Insurance

★ 4.7 · 14 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Warren Insurance Group - A Highstreet Partner

★ 4.6 · 64 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

NC Farm Bureau Insurance

★ 4.6 · 40 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Kiley Egan: Allstate Insurance

★ 4.6 · 27 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Carolina Planning Insurance

★ 4.5 · 53 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Kevin Bolton: Allstate Insurance

★ 4.4 · 95 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Protective Agency

★ 4.4 · 17 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Nationwide Insurance: Herb Townes

★ 4.4 · 10 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Nationwide Insurance: Walker Y. Worth

★ 4.2 · 20 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Affordable Car Insurance of Fayetteville

★ 4.2 · 5 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Insurance Service Center

★ 4.1 · 44 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Tolar Agency

★ 4.1 · 15 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Southeastern Insurance Services (SIA Group Partner)

★ 3.9 · 7 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Cape Fear Insurance: Allstate Insurance

★ 3.6 · 28 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

NC Farm Bureau Insurance

★ 3.6 · 14 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Superior Insurance Agency

★ 3.2 · 47 reviews
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

Steven Brown Insurance Agency

No rating yet
Insurance Agency · Fayetteville

/ HelpCommon Questions

How do I choose a reliable insurance agency in Fayetteville?+

Start with the rating — look for a insurance agency holding 4.5 stars or higher with a healthy number of recent reviews, which signals consistent, current service. Confirm they're properly licensed and insured for the work you need, and read a few reviews to see how they handle problems, not just praise. The listings below are sorted by Google rating to make this easier.

What's the typical cost of a insurance agency in Fayetteville?+

Pricing varies widely by the scope of the job, materials, and how urgent the work is, so there's no single rate. The most reliable approach is to contact two or three insurance agencies directly for a quote on your specific situation. Use the "View on Google Maps" or "Visit Website" buttons on each listing to reach out.

Are these insurance agencies verified?+

Yes. Every listing is sourced from public Google Business Profile data — business name, rating, and review count — collected by our own crawl. We show only what's already public; we don't add or alter business details.

How can I contact a insurance agency?+

Click "View on Google Maps" to get directions, hours, and the business's public contact options, or "Visit Website" to reach them online. We don't publish private phone numbers or email addresses here — the business's own Google profile and website are the right place to get in touch.

I'm a business owner — how do I update or remove my listing?+

Go to publicleads.com/your-business. You can remove your business or an email address, or fix your phone or email there; we email a confirmation link first, and nothing changes until it is used. For anything else, email support@publicleads.com.

Is your business on this list? Remove it or fix its phone or email. Not on it? Add your business.